Page last updated: Wednesday, January 07, 2009
A 'binge' is not a binge by Professor Dwight Heath
I have voiced my disapproval of the 'novel' way in which Henry Wechsler and many journalists and critics of drinking have defined the term 'binge' as the consumption of 5 or more drinks in a day by a male or 4 by a female before. My point is that it does violence to the traditional meaning of the term (which implied considerably higher consumption) plus it grossly mislabels patterns of drinking that involve 5 or more drinks per day without any impairment.

It was surprising and gratifying therefore to find that my concerns have been echoed by ' The Inter-Association Task Force on Alcohol and other Substance Abuse Issues' -a coalition of 21 Higher Education Associations. According to D.Hunter, who heads the task force and is a Director of BACCHUS and GAMMA, Government officials and researchers should stop using the term 'binge drinking' with reference to the student pattern. Their concern is that it mislabels students by lumping them with much heavier drinking that is problematic and widely recognised as dangerous.

Henry Wechsler responded to this criticism in the Chronicle of Higher Education (15th September 2000)by saying that students themselves use the term 'binge'.

In analysing Wechsler's own studies

('College alcohol use: a full or empty glass?'Journal of American College Health 47:247-252 1999) it is admitted that the tendency to view college drinking with alarm does not fit with the data reported - college drinking has decreased in recent years and their study notes that' .. the median number of drinks per week for frequent binge drinkers was 14.5..' That means that almost half of the so called frequent binge drinkers actually have less than 2 drinks a day - ie the US Dietary Guidelines definition of moderate drinking for males. What could more dramatically prove the crucial importance of drinking patterns than that simple numerical observation?They also note that frequent binge drinkers(19%) consumed the majority of alcohol (68%) and that when norms are considered across all Colleges, the median number of drinks at 1.5 per student per week is very low.

no website link
All text and images © 2003 Alcohol In Moderation.