Let us review today the results of mostly recent reports of the
effects upon health of components of wine other than alcohol.
As we have been discussing in these commentaries, moderate consumption
of wine and other beverage alcohol is associated with a longer
and healthier life than that of abstainers, an observation supported
by a great mass of evidence. Much of the benefit, at least 50
percent, appears to be derived from the alcohol itself, which,
when abused, is the only component of wine that adversely affects
health. Alcohol's health benefits chiefly favor the cardiovascular
system, and are dramatically reflected in reduced risks of atherosclerotic
heart attacks, ischemic strokes, and limb amputations due to compromised
There are other components of wine that contribute to the same
benefits, but they are more complex and variable, and less precisely
Scientific views on these compounds are not unanimous. These are
mostly polyphenolic flavonoids, which can be referred to as antioxidants,
according to their most attractive function. They are, of course,
found in grapes, chiefly the skins, so their concentrations tend
to be higher in red wines (skins participate in fermentation)
than white (skins separated). Their functions in the vine are
only partially known--antifungal, for one. These antioxidants
are much less available in other beverages. Among the best known
and most biologically active are resveratrol, quercetin, and the
The antioxidants with which we are concerned are a class of phytochemicals,
that is, compounds of vegetable origin. They are not exclusive
to grapes, although grapes are relatively richly endowed with
them. They are also found in allium vegetables (onion, leek, garlic,
shallot), broccoli, spinach, blueberries, strawberries, tea and
For some time there was doubt about whether antioxidants could
be absorbed when ingested and whether they were biologically potent.
By now the doubts have been resolved in favor of the antioxidants.
They appear to be even more active than the more renowned antioxidant
vitamins A, C, and E.
The average man lived to age 43 early in the twentieth century.
Enormous gains were made, largely resulting from prevention and
treatment of infectious diseases by public health measures, immunizations,
antibiotics, and improved general medical techniques, and from
improved surgical techniques and blood transfusions. We appear
to be approaching a plateau, with the only clearly visible gains
to be made the control of human-engendered carnage, of poverty-related
afflictions, and the elimination of diseases caused by tobacco.
The solutions to other plagues still elude us.
At or near the top of causes of death and disability are diseases
of the heart and blood vessels, cancer, and degenerative disorders.
Free radicals and oxidation figure heavily in the causation and
aggravation of these ills. Free radicals, not a political term,
are high reactive compounds produced normally as the body uses
oxygen. Smoking, radiation, and certain chemicals enhance their
production, thus straining, sometimes overwhelming, the body's
natural enzyme-mediated antioxidant defense system. This is why
there is so much interest in importing additional antioxidants,
those derived from food and drink. Look at a partial list of diseases
suspected of being able to be relieved by antioxidants: heart
attack, stroke, other complications of blood-vessel disease, cancer,
Alzheimer's disease and other dementias and degenerative disorders,
immune dysfunction, cataract, macular degeneration. Aging itself
may be retarded by antioxidants. Precise formulas for each of
us are not yet possible - we have much to learn. Antioxidants
may not always be entirely benign.
Recent studies of the cardiovascular system report reduction of
risk of heart attack in the elderly by a diet high in vitamin
A, but not vitamin C or E, reduction in risk of ischemic stroke
associated with the antioxidants of fruits and vegetables (but
no benefit from vitamins A, C, or E), and improved coronary artery
function apparently due to vitamin C. The antioxidants of wine
and grape juice favorably modulate the blood clotting that climaxes
heart attacks and strokes, and help further by relaxing blood
vessels and inhibiting the oxidation of LDL (the "bad") cholesterol
to its dangerous form. Similar, but less-established benefits
may result from the antioxidant flavonoids found in tea and chocolate,
virtually identical to those of wine.
Second in importance to their cardiovascular benefits are wine's
antioxidants' actions against cancer. Likely we are just beginning
to peel off layers of understanding. By both antibacterial effects
and by scavanging destructive superoxide to reduce tissue injury,
these compounds may prevent cancers of the stomach and other organs.
Quercetin has been noted to inhibit the growth of cancer and leukemia
cells, and to potentiate anticancer chemotherapy. One report has
resveratrol initiating a process one might term cancer-cell suicide,
but another suggests that antioxidant vitamins may do the opposite,
resulting in larger brain tumors in mice. (No harm comes to cancer-free
mice of this strain). Diligent science is hard.
The rest of the demonstrated or suspected benefits of the antioxidants
that are found in wine are in earlier days yet than those already
Improved brain and muscle function has been found associated with
moderate wine consumption and with supplementation with blueberries,
strawberries, and spinach. Among a number of studies indicating
that moderate wine consumption correlates with preservation of
mental capacity, that comparing aging twins is particularly impressive.
The co-twin of each pair who averaged one to two drinks per day
scored higher intellectually than their counterparts who drank
significantly more or significantly less.
A number of very nasty bacteria and viruses are inactivated by
wine and by grapes (but, surprisingly, in some cases not by alcohol).
One report suggests that antioxidants may help prevent toxemia
Finally, a most important subject, weight control. Long noted
but unexplained has been a disparity between the number of alcohol
calories ingested and weight. A peek behind the mystery may be
offered by the recent observation that catechin polyphenols (flavonoid
antioxidants, as found in wine, green tea, etc.) stimulate the
"burning" of body fat.
An ascetical might be inclined to ask why not eat just the fruits
and veggies, and shun alcohol. Fear not, there are reasons enough.
Alcohol in moderation contributes at least half of wine's cardiovascular
benefits, and likely provides numerous other health benefits,
but little, if any, risk. It may enhance the desired actions of
the antioxidants, and, when combined with antioxidants in the
enriching form of wine, its package can't be beat.
* Dr. Finkel, an award-winning wine writer, clinical professor
of medicine at Boston University Medical Center, and chairman
of the Committee on Health of the Society of Wine Educators, comments
regularly in The Wine News on the interrelationships of wine and
1. Finkel HE: Wine and health: a review and perspective. J Wine
Res 1996; 7:157-196.
2. Norrie P: Red wine versus white wine--is there a difference
in health benefit? AIM 1999; 8 (Nov/Dec):14-15.
3. Landvik S: The Protective Role of Antioxidants in the Aging
Process. LaGrange, IL, VERIS Research Summary, July 1999.
4. Kipstein-Grobusch K, Geleijnse JM, den Breeijen JH, et al:
Dietary antioxidants and risk of myocardial infarction in the
elderly: the Rotterdam Study. Am J Clin Nutr 1999; 69:261-266.
5. Josipura KJ, Ascherio A, Manson JE, et al: Fruit and vegetable
intake in relation to risk of ischemic stroke. JAMA 1999; 282:1233-1239.
6. Ascherio A, Rimm EB, Hernn MA, et al: Relation of consumption
of vitamin E, vitamin C, and carotenoids to risk for stroke among
men in the United States. Ann Intern Med 1999; 130: 963-970.
7. Pace-Asciak CR, Rounova O, Hahn SE, et al: Wine and grape juices
as modulators of platelet aggregation in healthy human subjects.
Clin Chim Acta 1996; 246:163-182.
8. Solzbach U, Hornig B, Jeserich M, et all: Vitamin C improves
endothelial dysfunction of epicardial coronary arteries in hypertensive
patients. Circulation 1997; 96:1513-1519.
9. Stein JH, Keevil JG, Wiebe DA, et al: Purple grape juice improves
endothelial function and reduces the suceptibility of LDL chosterol
to oxidation in patients with coronary artery disease. Circulation
10. Geleijnse JM, Launer LJ, Hofman A, et al: Tea flavonoids may
protect against atherosclerosis: the Rotterdam study. Arch Intern
Med 1999; 159:2170-2174.
11. Arts ICW, Hollman PCH, Kromhout: Chocolate as a source of
tea flavonoids. Lancet 1999; 354:488.
12. Heart Outcome Prevention Evaluation Study Investigators: Vitamin
E supplementation and cardiovascular events in high-risk patients.
N Engl J Med 2000; 342:154-160.
13. Finkel HE: Wine vs. cancer: next chapter. Wine News 1998-1999;
14. Raloff J: Green tea belittles cancer. Sci News 1999; 155:15.
15. Raloff J: Antioxidants may help cancers thrive. Sci News 2000;
16. Joseph JA, Shukitt-Hale B, Denisova NA, et al: Reversals of
age-related declines in neuronal signal transduction, cognitive,
and motor behavioral deficits with blueberry, spinach, or strawberry
dietary supplementation. J Neurosci 199; 19:8114-8121.
17. Konowalchuk J. Speirs JI: Virus inactivation by grapes and
wines. Appl Environ Microbial 1976; 32: 757-763.
18. Konowalchuk J, Speirs: Antiviral effect of commercial juices
and beverages. Appl Environ Microbiol 1978; 35:1219-1220.
19. Chappell LC, Seed PT, Briley AL, et al: Effect of antioxidants
on the occurrence of pre-eclampsia in women at increased risk:
a randomized trial. Lancet 1999; 354: 810-816.
20 Dullo AG, Duret C, Rohrer D, et al: Efficacy of a green tea
extract rich in catechin polyphenos and caffeine in increasing
24-h energy expenditure and fat oxidation in humans. Am J Clin
Nutr 1999; 70:1040-1045
21. Durak I, Cimen MYB, Buyukkocak S, et al: The effect of red
wine on blood antioxidant potential. Current Med Res Opinion 1999;
22. Durak I, Avci A, Kacmaz M, et al: Comparison of antioxidant
potentials of red wine, white wine, grape juice and alcohol. Current
Med Res Opinion 1999; 15:316-320.